All cheat sheets

Australian context · reviewed November 2026

Consent and Rogers v Whitaker

Australian consent law turns on material risk, set by the High Court in 1992. Expect it in any procedure, isotretinoin, biologic or cosmetic question.

What to know

Rogers v Whitaker (1992)
A doctor must warn of a material risk. A risk is material if a reasonable person in the patient’s position would be likely to attach significance to it, or if the doctor knows or should know that this particular patient would. The patient set the standard, not a body of medical opinion.
Valid consent
Given by a person with capacity, voluntarily, specific to the procedure, and informed about risks, benefits, alternatives (including doing nothing) and costs.
Capacity and minors
Adults are presumed to have capacity. A minor may consent if they understand the treatment fully (the Gillick principle, adopted in Australia in Marion’s case). Substitute decision-makers and guardianship rules vary by state.
Informed financial consent
Patients should know likely out-of-pocket costs before treatment. This matters in private dermatology and cosmetic work.
Interpreters
Use a professional interpreter, not family, for consent. TIS National provides free interpreting for eligible medical practitioners.

How panels probe it

  • “A 16-year-old wants isotretinoin and doesn’t want her parents told. How do you approach consent?”
  • “What risks would you discuss before excising a lesion on the nose?”
  • “How is the Australian consent standard different from where you trained?”

Sample question

You are consenting a patient for a wide local excision on the face. What do you cover and why?

A framework for your answer

  1. Check capacity, language needs and that they want to make the decision.
  2. Diagnosis, the purpose of the procedure and the alternatives, including no treatment.
  3. Material risks: scarring, infection, bleeding, nerve damage, recurrence, further surgery, plus anything this patient cares about (a performer, a wedding).
  4. Costs and follow-up. Time to ask questions.
  5. Document the discussion, not just the signature.
Answer questions like this aloud, freeMarked against an Australian-practice rubric, with follow-ups.

Where candidates lose marks

  • Describing consent as getting a form signed.
  • Using the doctor-centred standard (Bolam) instead of material risk.
  • Using a relative to interpret.

Read the source

A study summary, not legal or regulatory advice. Laws, PBS listings, MBS items and Board standards change; check the source before relying on a detail.

Further reading on Medbrella